Control system.



K. A. SIMMON & A. J. HALL.

CONTROL SYSTEM;

APPLICATION FILED JULY 13, 19-14.

2 SHEETSSHEET I.

Patented Aug. 14, 1917.

WITNESSES:

ATTORNEY K. A. SIMMON & A. J. HALL.

CONTROL SYSTEM.

APPLICATION FILED JULY 13. 1914.

INVENTOR ATTORNEY UNITED STATES PATENT .oFFroE.

KARL A. SIMMON, OF EDGEWOOD PARK, AND ARTHUR J. HALL, 6F WILKINSBJUBG" PENNSYLVANIA, ASSIGNORS 'I'O WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC AND KANUIAO'IUBING comrmpn CORPORATION or PENNSYLVANIA.

' ooN'rnoI. srsrnm.

Specification of Letters Patent.

Patented Aug. 14, 1917.

Application filed July 18, 1914;. Serial No. 850,753.

To all whom it may concern:

yBe it known that we, KARL A. SnsMoN, a citizen of the United States, and a resident of Edgewoodlark in the county of Allegheny and State of Pennsylvania, and An- THUR J. HALL, a subject of the King of Great Britain, and a. resident ofgWilkinsburg, in the county ofAllegheny and State of Penns lvania, have invented a new and useful mprovement in Control Systems, of which 7 the following is a specification.

controlling the driving units or motors of an electric locomotive or train of electric vehioles in such manner that a predetermined division of the load between the driving unitsshall be maintained at all times, irrespective of variations in the mechanical construction and electrical characteristics of the several motors or their accessory governing apparatus, or differences in the d1ameters of the driving wheels.

- Another object of our invention is to provide a control system of the above indicated class which shall be adapted for multiple unit operation and which shall automatically correct for the inherent differences inthe operation of the various motors which may result from any cause whatsoever.

further object ofour invention is to provide adequate and reliable automatic means for 'proportioning the total load which is carried in common by a pluralit of sets of driving motors, which means sha l embody, first, means for balancing the loads between the motors of each set, and, second, which shall embody other means for balancing the loads between the several sets of driving motors. y

In another aspect, one of the objects of our invention is tosecure the desired division of load through the agency of electroresponsive devices which are adapted to respond to differences in the amounts of power taken by the several motors or sets of motors and which shall act under predetermined load conditions to reduce the load carried by the motor or set of motors which is relatively overloaded, and, concurrently, to increase the load carried by the remaining motor or set of motors which carries less than its proper share of the load. v More specifically, it is the object of our invention to provide torque operated controlling devices for automatically governing the several,electro-pneumatically operated liquid rheostats associated with the several motors of a double unit locomotive, whereby the motors of the driv'n trucks of one unit of the locomotive sha divide their lead in predetermined proportions, while the total load of the locomotive, as awhole, shall be'balanoed in predetermined proportions between the several locomotive half units. In case of'a single locomotive unit having a pair of driving motors upon each of two trucks, the loads of the motors of each truck are properly riLigided, while 'the loads of the driving truc considered as units, are also proportioned.

With present day manufacturing methods, it is practically impossible to commercially construct motors and operatin mechanisms therefor, which shall be i entical with respect to electrical characteristics and operating qualities and, therefore, in electrically propelled vehicles of the types referred to, there is usually a tendency for certain of the motors to take a greater portion of the load than is intended. I

Furthermore, when locomotives have been in service for considerable periods of time, the wear u on the driving wheels become so excessive t at it is necessary to remove the wheels and turn them down to a smaller diameter. It may happen, therefore, that the wheels of a locomotive are not always of the same diameter, inasmuch as i it is rarely that all of the wheels wear to the same degree and hence, only a portion of them have to be machined. Obviously, differences in the diameters of the driving wheels also effects differences in' the motor operation with respect to the load carried thereby.

. According to our invention, we propose to provide means for overcoming the difficulis a diagrammatic view of the main circuit 7 connections and apparatus of a system of control embodying our invention certain of are omitted'for the sake of clearness; F ig2 is a diagrammatic view of the auxiliar control circuits which are associated wit v and are governed by certain of the apparatus shown in Fig.1; and Fig. 3 is a diagrammatic view of av double unit electric locomotive provided with electric propelling motors that are adapted to be controlled by the system set forth in Figs. 1 and 2.

In order to comprehensively set forth our control system and its mode of operation, we shall first describe its general operation with respect to the main circuit connections, as shown in Fig. 1, and then describe the control circuit connections thereof and their respective functions.

Referring to Fig. 3, a locomotive 1 com prises a plurality of half units 2 and 3 that are conveniently associated .by a suitable articulated link 4, the half unit 2 embodying a plurality of driving trucks 5 and 6, while the half unit 3 comprises drivin trucks 7 and 8. The driving trucks 5 an 6 of the first half unit are respectively equipped with polyphase induction drivin motors M1 and M2 and motors M3 and 4 areassociated with the trucks 7 and 8 respectively.

Reference may now be had to Fig. 1 in which the system shown comprises a polyphase supply circuit 12 that is adapted to deliver energy to the driving motors M1, M2, M3 and M4 through a plurality of line switches LS1 and LS2 that are adapted to be electrically operateda.' lurality of liquid rheostats LRl, L112 LE respectlvely governingt e operation of the respective motors M1, M2, M3 "and M4; a

. plurality of operating devices termed balanced Sressure o eratmg mechanisms OD1, OD2, D3 and D4 for respectively actuating the s veral liquid rheostats, whereby'the level of t e electrol te therein may be'regu lated, a pluralit o torque devices TM and M respective v associated with the sets of motors M1 and M2 and motors M3 and M4 and adapted to respond to differences in load between motors of each set; a plurality of controllers CM and CM respectively associated with the torque devices TM and TM for adjustin the circuit connections of the operating devices 'OD1- and CD2 and dev1cesOD3 and CD4; a pluralityof torque devices TL and TL re ectively associated,

. with the several locomotive half units .2 and 3 and responsive'to relative load conditions- 3 and LE4 for.

like construction and each embodies primary windings P and secondary windings S, which are conveniently connected in delta relation, the primary windings P being adapted to receive ener from the su pie circuit 12 and the secon ary windings b ing connected to the respective liquid rheostats LE1 LE2, LE3 and LE4. The motors M1 and M2 are connected in multiple circuit and are supplied with energy through the line switch LS1, while the motors M3 and M4 are also connected in multiple and reiegve their energy through the line switch 2. The several li uid rheostats LE1, LE2 LE3 and LE4 em ody like arrangements oi parts and each comprises a tank 15 having a bottom discharge opening 16 and a centre ly disposed tubular member 17 communicating therewith and projecting upwardly into the rheostat to a height corresponding to the lower ends of a plurality of electrodes 18..

A tubular sliding r ulatable valve 20 is disposed within the tu ular member 17 and is adapted to be raised and lowered in position for determining the height of electrolyte which is continuously admitted into the rheostat tank 15 through an inlet port 21. The electrolyte normally establishes a flush level which corresponds to the upperend of the regulating valve 20, it being understood that the excess of electrolyte overflows and is disposed of through the bottom discharge opening 16.

In order to actuate the several regulating valves 20, the operating devices OD1, OD2, OD3 and OD4 are employed. Each of these devices comprises an operating cylinder 25, the upper end of which is provided with an electrically operated magnet valve marked Ofl1 (the numeral designating the rheostat with' which the valve is associated), and

the lower end is provided with another elec- Y I of operation of these valves will not be described further inasmuch as theyare common in the art. Each cylinder 25-is provided with a movable piston 26, the latter being connected to the regulating valve 20 of the corresponding rheostat by a' rod 27 whereby said regulating valve 20 is raised and lowered in position in accordance with the movement of the piston 26.

" The torque devices TM and TM, may be 180.

of any well known construction for effecting rotative' movements in opposite directlons 1n accordance with the power conditions of the 'motor clrcuits, although we prefer to employ devices similar to that set forth in our co-pending application, Serial No. 843,929 and filed June 9, 1914. For illustrative purposes we have shown the various torque devices, as embodyin a plurality of stationary coils 30 and 31 an a-coiiperating rotatable member 32 which is mechanically connected to the corresponding auxiliary controller CM, or CM as the case may be. The coil 30 serves as the voltage coil of the device and is connected across two of the motor lead conductors 35 and36, while the coil 31 is the series coil and is connected in a local series circuit which includes windings 38 and 39 of a plurality of series transformers 40 and 41, the primary windings 42 and 43 of which are respectively connected in series circuit with the motor lead conductors 35 and 35 that are respectively connected to the motors M1 and M2.

It is manifest, therefore, that when the loads carried by the several motors M1 and M2 are substantially equal, no' current flows through the series winding 31 of the torque device TM,, inasmuch as the series transformers 40 and 41 neutralize each other. In the event of a greater amount of power be .ing taken by one motor than is used by the other, the action of one of the series transformers will over-balance that of the other .overcome one orthe other thereof.

The torque devices TL, and TL are of like construction to those just described, and each embodies a voltage coil 50 that is connected across the motor lead conductors 35 and 36, and a series coil 51 which is connected in series circuit with a secondary winding 52 of a series transformer53, theprimary winding 54 of which is'connected in series with the motor lead conductor 35. The circuit which includes the series coil 51 and thetransformersecondary coil 52 terminates in contact terminals 55 and 56, and the corresponding terminals 55 and 56 associated with the several torque devices TL, and-TL, are adapted to be interconnected by train line conductors or jumpers 55 and 56 under operating conditions when the two half units 2 and 3 of the locomotive.

are operatively connected,

With this arran ment of apparatus, if the motors M1 and M2 of the locomotive half unit 2 carry more than their share of the total load, the several torque devices TL, and TL will be rotated in one direc tion, while ifthe load conditions are reversed, the operation of said devices is in the opposite direction and, consequently, their associated controllers are correspondingly actuated.

The line switches LS, and LS are severally of the'three-pole type and are provided with operating electromagnets 58.

Reference may now be had to Fig. 2 in which a plurality of master controllers MC, and MC of like construction are employed in connection with the control circuits of each of thelocomoti'ge half units, for manually governing the concurrent operation of the several operating devices CD1, CD2, OD3 and CD4, which respectively actuate the liquid rheostats LE1, LE2, LE3 and LR4.

Each of the master controllers MC comprises a movable conducting segment 60 and a plurality of stationary terminals B+, 61, 62 and 63 which are adapted to coiiperatively engage the segment 60 along the position-indicating lines lower, hold and raise. The several contact terminals 61, 62'and 63 are respectively connected to train line conductors 61, 62 and 63 and a plurality of auxiliary control batteries B have their negative terminals connected to a train line conductor B. Corresponding train line conductors of the several locomotive half units'are interconnected in the usual manner by means of suitable jumpers 65, whereby the system, as a whole, is adapted for multiple unit operation.

The energization of the several off and on electrically operated valves that are associated with the operating devices of rheostats LRl and LR2 is governed by the torque operated controllers CL, and CM,,

- while corresponding valves of the rheostats LR3 and LR4 have their energizin circuits interlocked through and ad uste by the torque actuated controllers CL and CM,. The controller CM, is adapted to adjust the circuit connections of the off and on valves of the locomotive ,unit 1 in accordance with the load conditions of its driving motors, whereby the load of said motors is properly proportioned, while the controller CM similarly adjusts the division of load between the motors of the locomotive unit 2, .Moreover, controllers CL, and CL serve to shift the connections of the corresponding off and on magnet valves for equalizing the. loads between. the several locomotive half units 2 and 3.

Assuming the apparatus and the circuit bring the several driving motors up to speed, one of the master controllers, for instance, controller M0,, is moved into its raise position, thereby completing a circuit from the positive terminal of the battery Bwhich includes contact terminals B+, conducting segment 60 contact terminal 61, conductor 61, energizing coils 58 of line switches LS1 and LS2 and conductor B to the other .onemainv branch including the following contact members of the controllers CL and CM,; terminal 70,'segment 72 and terminal 71,"where the branch again divides, one portion'thereof traversingcontact terminals 73 and 74 which are bridged by conducting segment 75, energizing coil of magnet valve on1 and conductor l3--- to the battery, while the other portion traverses contact terminal 76, conducting segment 77, contact trminal 78, energizing coil of magnet valve on-2 and conductor B' to the battery. The other main branch includes contact terminal 80," conducting segment 81, contact terminal 82 where'the circuit again divides, one portion of which-traverses contact terminal 85, conducting se ent 86, contact terminal 87, energizing 0011 of magnet valve on-'3 and conductor B to the battery, and the other portion thereof traverses contact terminal 88, conducting segment. 89,

contact terminal 90, energizing coil of magnet valve on4 and conductor B- to the battery. Having completed the circuits just traced, the several on valve magnets are energized and are actuated into their open positions whereby operating fluid is admitted beneath the movable pistons 26 'of the several operating devicesODl, OD2, 01% and CD4. Balanced. pressures acting upon the several pistons 26 are, therefore, obtained. l

sen another circuit is'established 50m contact terminal B+ which'includes conducting segment .60, contact terminal'63 and conductor 63 where the circuit divides, one

- inain branch including contact terminal '93, conducting segment 94', and contact terminal 95, where the circuit again divides, one

portion thereof traversin contact terminal 96, conducting segment 9 contact terminal 98, ene ing coil of magnet valve ofi-1 i and con uctorB- to the battery, the other portion thereof'trayersing contact terminal 100, conducting segment 101, contactterminal 102, energizing coil -of magnet valve.

.thereby intelruptin the circuits of 111 0 ofi2 and conductorB- to the battery. The other main branch of the circuit under consideration, includes contact terminal 103, conducting segment 104, and contact terminal 105, where the circuit divides, one portion thereof traversing contact terminal 106 conducting segment 107, contact termina 108, and energizing coil of magnet valve oif3 to the battery, while the other portion-thereof traverses contact terminal 110 conducting segment 111, contact terminal 112 and energizing coil of magnet valve ofl'4 to the battery. The several ofl valve magnets are, therefore, energized and closed to the supply of operating fluid, while permitting the operating fluid in the upper ends of the several cylinders 25 to be released to the atmosphere.

Underthese conditions, unbalanced ressure con'ditions obtain, and, by reason t era- 7 of, the several movable istons 26 and their associated regulatin va ves 20 are raised in position concurren y. This action results in a corresponding rise in the level of the electrolyte within the several rheostats LE1, LE2, LR3 and LR4 and, consequently, the several driving motors M1, M2, M3 and M4 are concurrent y started into opfration. So long as the master controller C occupies its raise position, the secondary resistance of the several'motors is gradually eliminated and said motors continue to accelerate, as will be understood.

When the desired speed of o eration is attained, the master controller C, is moved into its hold position, in which the conducting segment thereof becomes disengaged from the conducting terminal 68 the ofl' magnet va ves and permitting said valves to be returned to their open in which operating fluid is agaln admitted above the several pistons 26 and the upward movement of the ating valves 20 is, therefore, arrested. uch as the pressures act' upon the several pistons 26 are thenbalanced, the regulating valves 20 .are maintained in their respective positions and the motors operate at uniform speed.

In order to decrease the speed of the motors, it is only 11 ms: to move the master controller MC to its lower position, in which conducting segment becomes disengaged from contact terminal 62 and the circuits of all of the on valve ma ets are'interrupted. The deenergization o the on valve magnets permits them to return to their closed position, whereby the lower ends of the several cylinders are opened to. the atmosphere. Inasmuch as the upper ends of the cylinders are supplied with operating fluid, unbalanced pressures obtain and the several movable pistons 26, together with their associated regulating valves 20,. are moved downwardly'to either its raise operated at any desired uniform speed, or

may be retarded, at the will of the operator by manipulating the controller MC to hold or lower position. 7

Having set forth the normal manually controlled operation of the system, we shall now consider the mode of operation of the automatic portion thereof which effects the predetermined proportioning of the loads with respect to the individual'motors of each locomotive unit and with respect to several sets of motors of the respective locomotive units. For purposes-of consideration, it will be assumed that the master controller MC, occupies its raise position and that the several operating devices CD1, CD2, CD3 and, CD4 are concurrently-performing their intended functions in raising their associated-regulating valves 20, whereby the several motors are gradually accelerated. If, under these conditions, motor M1 has a tendency to carry a greater'por tion than its proper share of the load, irrespective of whether this tendency results from diiferencesin mechanical construction or electrical characteristics of the motor,

in the operation of its operating device CD1,

or whether itbe-the result of differences in wheel diameters, the torque device TM is brought into action in the following manner.

The excess of power taken by the motor M1 causes the current in the secondary winding 38 of the series transformer 40 to predominate over that in, the winding 39 of the series transformer 41, whereby a torque is produced in the device TM tending to rotate the controller CM into its position 1, as shown in Fig. 2. In so doing, the several contact terminals 96, 98, 73and 74 become disengaged from the cooperating conducting, segments 97 and 75, whereby the valve magnets off-1 and on1 are deenergized. Concurrently, contact terminal 100 becomes separated from conducting segment 101, while contact terminal 102-immediately is brought into engagement with conducting segment 77. Thus, the energizing circuits of valve magnets on'-2 and ofi'2 are maintained closed, and, hence, the operation of the operating device OD2 continues 'as before, whereby the motor M2 is inreturn the controller CM to its neutral or 0 position, after which the normal accelerationis resumed.

Without further description, it will be understood that similar adjustments of circuit connections and similar operations of the motors will be effected in case any of the other motors tend to carry more than its intended share of the load. By this means the load between any pair of motors of a single set is properly proportioned.

If, for any reason whatsoever, the motors M1 and M2 of the locomotive unit 2 tend to carry a greater portion of the load than the *motors M3 and M4 of the other locomotive unit 3, the efi'ectof the series transformer 53 which is traversed by the total current of the motors M1 and M2 predominates over that of the corresponding series transformer which is influenced by the total current of the motors M3 and M4 and, hence, the several torque devices TL and TL are rotated in corresponding directions by reason of the torque developed therein. The associated controllers CL and GL therefore, are moved into their positions 1 against the action of one of the opposing springs.

As the controller CL is moved, its cooperating contact members become disengaged moved downwardly to efiect concurrent speed reductions of the motors M1 and M2. On the other hand, the controller GL in ,moving into its position 1, transfers its control circuits in such manner as to maintain the energization of the several magnet valves ofl3, on' on4 and off-4, 'so that the normal acceleration of the motors M3 and M4 is undisturbed. Clearly, the reduction of load upon motors M1 and M2 and the increase thereof on motors M3 and M4 will then eflect an equalization of the loads,

after which the torque devices TL and TL are returned to their initial positions and the normal concurrent acceleration of all of the driving motors is resumed. Similar adjustments of circuit connections are, of course, effected in the event that the greater portion of the load is carried bythe driving motors oflocomotive unit 3, and no description thereof is deemed necessa In the system described, a plurality of torque devices TL and TL are employed for the reason that it is desired to make each set of control circuits for the several locowith a plurality o motive units a complete system, in. order that any two half units may be operated in accordance with the usual multiple unit op-.

eration. It is evident that if particular 10- comotive half units are to be operated per manently together, only a single torque device TL v will be required for balancing the loads between the several half units, in which case, the contact members of both of the controllers TL and TL will necessarily be combined upon a single control drum. The arrangement of parts, circuit connections and the mode of operation, therefore will be comparable to that of either of the.torque devices TM, or TM These and other modifications in the circuit connections and arrangement of control apparatus may be'eflected without departing from the spirit and scope of our invention, and all such modifications are "intended to be covered by the appended claims.

We claim as our invention:

1. In a control s stem, the combination electric driving units adapted to work upon a common load, of means embodying a torque device responsive to ower conditions upon said driving units an having a current winding and a potential winding for regulating the operation thereof.

2. In acontrol s stem, the combination with a pluralit 0% electric driving units adapted to wor upon a common load, of

- means embodying a torque device and havsive to mutu ing a current windin and a potential winding electrically associated with said driving units and influenced by the respective power loads for proportioning the load between the driving units.

3. In a control s stem, the combination with a pluralit 0 electric driving units adapted to wor upon a common load, of

means embodying a-"torque device and having a current winding and a potential winding adapted to be mutually influenced by the several unit power loads for automatically controlling the o eration of said units.

4. In a contro adapted to wor upon a common load, of Ifieans embodying a torque device and having a current winding and a potential winding. res onsive to mutual power conditions upon t e-several units, and control means governed thereby for controlling the operation of said units.

5. In a control stem, the combination with a plum 't 0 electric driving units adapted to wor upon a common load, of means embod a torque device responadapted to governed by said control stem, the combination with a pluralit 0 electric driving units load, conditions upon the sevswitch for controlling the operation of said units.

6. In a control s stem, the combination with a plurality 0 electric driving units adapted to work upon a common load, of means embodying a torque device responsive to mutual load conditions u on the several units, a controller actuated by said to us device, a plurality of liquid rheostats or severally governing said units and electropneumatic means governed by said controller for actuating said rheostats.

7. In a control s stem, the combination with a pluralit 0 electric drivingunits adapted to wor upon a common load, of means embodying a torque device having a voltage winding and a current winding, respectively influenced by the driving unit voltage and by the diflerence in driving unit currents and means for governing the o eration of said units in accordance with e 86 action of said torque device.

8. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of electric motors adapted to work upon a common load, of means embodying a torque device having a voltage 90 winding and a current winding respective y influenced by motor voltage and by the difference in motor currents, and separate actuati mechanisms controlled by said torque evice for governing the operation 96 of said motors.

9. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of electric motors working upon a common load, and electrically controlled regulatable resistance devices for severally governing the operation of said motors, of a torque device responsive to differences in the loads upon said motors f or reversing the action of the governin device of the motor taking the greater loa 105 10. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of electric motors working upon a common load, and a 1plurality 0 speed regulating devices several y associated with said motors and each com rising a regulatable rheostat, a pneumatic evice for actuating said rheostat and a plurality of electrica y operated valves associated with said pneumatic device, of a torque 0 rated switching device responsive to di erences in load upon the several motors for controlling the energization of said electrically operated valves.

11. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of electric motors working upon a common load, of means for proportioning the load between said sets of motors, and means for proportioning the load between the motors of each set.

12. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of electric motors working upon a common load, of means responsive to circuit conditions for eflecting a predetermined division of load between said sets of motors, and other means for dividing the load between the motors of each set in predetermined proportions.

13. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of electric motors,

load between the motors of each set, and

other means embodying torque apparatus responsive to differences in load between said sets for proportioning the load between the several sets of motors.

15. In a multiple unit control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of motors working upon a common load, separate speed governing apparatus for each motor.

and means for concurrently controlling the operation of said apparatus, of automatic means associated with each set of motors.

for proportioning the load between said motors of each set and automatic means associated with each set of motors and cotiperating the one withthe other and with the corresponding first mentioned automatic means for proportioning the loads between the several sets of motors.

16. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of driving motors working upon a common load, a plurality of rheostats for said motors, and means for concurrently controlling the operation thereof under normal load conditions, of an electro-responsive controller for each set of motors for automatically controlling the operation of the associated rheostats and balancing the loads thereof, and other electro-r'esponsive control apparatus associated with each set of motors for cooperating with the first mentioned controllers for antomatically controlling the operation of the associated rheostats and balancing the loads between the severalsets of motors.

17. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of electric driving units adapted to work upon a common load, of power-responsive means dependent upon mutual load conditions upon the several units, an auxiliary controller operated by said means, and electrically operated means adapted to be governed by said controller for controlling the operation of said units.

18. In a control system, the combination with a plurality .of electric driving units adapted to work upon a common load, of

power-responsive means dependent upon mutual load conditions upon the several units, an auxiliary controller actuated by said means, and a plurality of electro-pneumatically operated device governed by said controller for regulating'the operation of said driving units.

19. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of electric motors working upon a common load, and" electrically controlled regulatable resistance devices for severally governing the operation of said motors, of power-responsive means dependent upon the differences in the loads upon said motors for influencing the action solely of the governing device associated with the motor taking the greater load.

20. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of electric motors working 1 upon a common load, and a plurality. of speed regulating devices severally associated with said motors, and each comprising an electrically operated means for regulating the operation of its associated motor and embodying a plurality of electrically operated valves, of a torque-operated swltch device responsive to diiferences in the power loads upon the several motors for controlvalves. 4 1 21. In a control system, the combinatio with a plurality of sets of electric motors working upon a common load, of automatic means for dividing the load between the said sets of motors and automatic means for dividing the load between the motors of each set.

22. In a control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of electric motors working upon a common load, of automatic means for proportioning the load between said sets of motors and between the motors of each set. 4

23. In a multiple unit control system, the combination with a plurality of sets of motors working upon a common load, separate speed-governing apparatus for each motor, and means for concurrently controlling the operation of said apparatus, of automatic means associated with each set of motors for acting conjointly'to proportion the loads between the motors of each set and to proportion the loads between the several sets of motors.

In testimony whereof, we have hereunto ling the action of said electrically operated subscribed our names this 6th day of July, 

